.
Feedback

FCPS: So Long, 'Pink Slime'

As national outcry over ammonia-treated beef continues, county schools say they'll replace hamburgers served in schools next month.

Amidst a national outcry over U.S. Department of Agriculture plans to purchase ammonia-treated ground beef for national school lunch programs, Fairfax County Public Schools has plans of its own to kiss the substance — dubbed "pink slime" — goodbye.

While FCPS does not receive beef products from the USDA, schools spokesman John Torre said the beef patties sold to county schools by another vendor do contain Lean Finely Textured Beef (LFTB), the "waste" meat and fat that is often ground and turned into processed meat products or combined with higher quality meat to make low-fat ground beef.

Because beef trim is often filled with E. Coli and salmonella, it's treated with ammonium hydroxide, creating "pink slime," a term coined by some scientists who claim the resulting product "isn't really beef."

Torre said the school district plans to finish off its current inventory of the patties — the only product with LFTB served by FCPS — and then serve 100 percent beef hamburger patties, a switch that will likely take effect across the county in mid-April.

Penny E. McConnell, director of food and nutrition services, wrote in a letter to parents this week that manufacturers are not required to list LFTB on their product ingredient lists.

"Just like any parent buying food at a grocery store or a restaurant, schools rely on the federal government to inspect and certify the safety of the foods they purchase. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), after consultation with the Food and Drug Administration, has determined that the use of ammonium hydroxide in the processing of LFTB is safe," McConnell wrote, which is why the schools have until now served the hamburger patties that include it.

The department contacted all providers of its beef products; Don Lee Farms, which sells the system its hamburger patties, was the only manufacturer who said it used the substance.

For the complete letter and table of beef products and suppliers, click on the media player above.

The hamburgers were a driving symbol used by Real Food For Kids, a grassroots group advocating for more whole, fresh foods in schools, to argue the county's food offerings need an overhaul: The hamburger patty currently served

"Why not just beef?" they've asked for the past year.

The upcoming switch is a big step forward in food reform, Real Food For Kids member and Vienna parent JoAnne Hammermaster said.

"Ammonium hydroxide — I don't think there's one parent that you can find in Fairfax County that would agree to go ahead and keep that in the beef," Hammermaster said. "[The switch] is a very positive thing. We’re very excited."

In response to cries across the country against the product — including a petition that had nearly 250,000 signatures Thursday night — the USDA said this week it will offer schools two types of ground meat to serve students.

The change comes as the schools' Food Services department prepares to undergo an independent assessment and analysis.

As part of its proposed fiscal year 2013 budget, the school board voted in February of ways to make FCPS school food healthier, led by an independent consultant.

The funds come from the Food and Nutrition Services budget, which is separate from FCPS' operating fund.

Torre could not confirm where the system is in that process, but Hammermaster, whose group gave early input into what the system should look for in a consultant, said she believes the system has nearly completed (or is preparing to send out) a request for proposal.

"Food Services is run very well right now. A lot of school districts struggle in their food services, so now the question is, how do we transition to selling more fresh, whole foods, and are there some ways we can start doing some of that here rather than bringing it in from elsewhere?" Hammermaster said.  

Among the questions the group has had about the system: why the schools' department can't reduce the additives found in other products; why it can't replace alternatives to processed, packaged foods — like grilled cheese wrapped and heated in plastic — with things like real cheese sandwiched by two slices of fresh bread; and how .

Some of those farmers, including Chris and Sara Guerre of , have given produce to Arlington County Public Schools for at least the past year.

"We need an assessment to tell us how to do that," Hammermaster said. "It's not an easy process and it takes a lot of time. That's why we think the assessment will help us plan and guide us one, three, five years down the road." 

Schools aren't the only ones affected by the "pink slime." The Huffington Post reported the beef is mixed into 70 percent of the ground beef sold at grocers around the country; meat-packers and other stores aren't required to label it LFTB, however, because the USDA still recognizes it as meat.

Giant Food announced Thursday it was working to convert its fresh and frozen store brand beef products to those that do not contain LFTB, though LFTB is "safe and in compliance with all USDA standards for lean beef," said a spokeswoman for Giant's Landover, Md., office, which oversees the chain's supermarket locations in the Greater Washington, D.C. area.

She said the stores believe it will take a few weeks to sell the current inventory of fresh and frozen products. Stores will post signs in the meat departments letting customers know when their fresh ground beef is LFTB-free, she said.

Giant also offers Certified Angus Beef, Nature’s Promise, and Laura’s Lean beef products, all of which are free of the substance.

Michael Burgess March 23, 2012 at 01:08 pm
Pure Pasty would like to confirm that none of their beef products contain the Pink Slime. We have checked it all out with our suppliers.
Glave M. March 23, 2012 at 02:26 pm
I never had a problem with beef byproduct as long as its pure. Just cookthe the heck out of it. I'm Chinese and we eat anything that moves! Haha. HOWEVER, I dislike the whole ammonia thing though. I'd rather keep the chemistry out of me.
Michele Menapace March 23, 2012 at 03:25 pm
These statements about rejecting beef containing pink slime are all well and good. However, given that:
1. the USDA doesn't require disclosure of pink slime content; 2. pink slime is cheap; 3. the only way to know if pink slime is present is by the admission of the distributor; How can anyone actually know what is in the food they are buying or eating? This applies to all parties mentioned in these recent reports--schools, grocery stores, etc. Consumers, store chains, school food directors must simply trust their suppliers. Does anyone know the "parents" who received Penny McConnell's March 19 letter? And what does her reference to Beef Products, Inc. have to do with FCPS? Ms. McConnell's letter says nothing about FCPS plans to switch in April to all-beef patties. But how does that move ensure FCPS isn't serving pink slime? After all, it isn't the non-meat additives that contain pink slime. And pink slime is considered, for labeling purposes, to be lean ground beef. Great article, Erica. Thank you.
Sandra March 23, 2012 at 03:27 pm
Would it be possible for someone in the media to contact the major companies that sell ground beef in this area to see who is selling ground beef that doesn't contain pink slime and publish a list? I know Giant is mentioned here, but what about Shopper's, Safeway, BJ's, Costco (they said their fresh ground beef doesn't contain it, don't know about their frozen), etc. I don't know of anyone who wants ammonium hydroxide in their food. If we all patronize the places that sell only ground beef without pink slime, the other companies would be forced to follow suit or lose all of their business. I'd love to know which restaurants (fast food & otherwise) use non-pink-slime ground beef as well.
Erica R. Hendry (Editor) March 23, 2012 at 04:28 pm
Sandra, we're working on a followup with grocery stores now. Stay tuned
Thanks for reading, Erica
Linda Kerr March 23, 2012 at 05:02 pm
My hope is that this kind of thing will force the USDA to change their regulations. There was enough noise about Trans Fat for so many years that they finally had to make changes with disclosing that. My hope is all of this is at least moving us in the right direction.
Mary S. March 23, 2012 at 09:30 pm
I thought that some of these stores stated yesterday that they will stop selling hamburger with "pink slime" in it. I sent an email to Wegman's to see what they are doing or have done. I usually buy their ground sirloin since regular hamburger (from other stores) has had a funky taste to it.
Here is a link to a video of the original whistleblower of pink slime: http://foodwhistleblower.org/learn-more/fic-conference-2011-videos/panel-2-speakers . His discussion is 35 minutes into the video. The first speaker is a whistleblower discussing contaminated peanuts. We need more inspectors or at least ones that are trained to do their job properly. I would like to have less windex in my food.
Mary S. March 23, 2012 at 09:33 pm
Linda,
Even though a product states that is is 0 % trans fat doesn't mean it is entirely 0 % free of trans fat. The government allows for a very small percentage in the product.
Rk March 24, 2012 at 01:38 am
The Dept. of Agriculture and FDA say it's safe.. That should be good enough right? (smile) Solyent Green anyone..
Stella Pekarsky March 24, 2012 at 02:04 pm
Thanks for the article, Erica, and the focus on what our school system allows to be fed to our children. I know many parents would love a follow up with Ms. McConnell, of FNS, regarding her statement that a letter was sent to parents. As an FCPS parent deeply concerned with the quality (or lack there of, in many respects), nobody with whom I have spoken, has received such a letter. We just wonder which parents received it, and why the rest of us were left out.
Mary Porter, CHC March 24, 2012 at 02:09 pm
Ms. McConnell says she wrote a letter to parents about the LFTB. Which parents did she sent it to, and when? I have not seen it, nor have any of my fellow FCPS parents.
deb werrlein March 24, 2012 at 02:59 pm
thanks for the article. a quick note: the photo you have here is actually a picture of separated chicken. The same photo was mistakenly posted on the blog, The Lunch Tray, by Bettina Siegel, the woman who started the petition against pink slime in public schools. she later removed the photo, realizing her mistake. Pink slime is still completely disgusting, it just doesn't look quite like this. Also, I think it is important to ask the school and the grocery stores for disclosure about what's in the food they sell, but as one commenter already noted, the system is so convoluted, and labeling so deceptive, it's hard to really know what you're getting. My solution is to buy local meat from farmers who I trust. There are lots of meat vendors at farmer's markets who will happily share information with you. I buy all of our meat from Polyface Farm, buying enough during the spring/summer/fall to freeze and last us through the winter. Perhaps this important altermative could be included in your follow up article on the grocery stores. thanks!
K Grau March 25, 2012 at 04:51 pm
Thank you, Real Food for Kids!!!!!!!! "Like" them on fb, everyone!
Joseph P. March 26, 2012 at 05:44 pm
this is good news but a question I have is why was it ever ok to use the pink slime? Pink slime is another reason people should become a vegetarian and not have to worry about it.
Tom Egly March 26, 2012 at 05:46 pm
Make kids lunches healthier? Simple. Get rid of the vending/snack/cola machines and limit the pizza to once a week if not less.
T Ailshire March 26, 2012 at 07:25 pm
Let me guess. In a few weeks, we'll start seeing stories about people who had to cut beef out of their lives completely because stores starting raising prices. Filler, in the form of lean finely textured beef, permits the 82%-lean (or whatever the lower grade is) to be less expensive.
Sandra March 27, 2012 at 11:55 am
The solution to that would be for companies to label their ground beef as containing pink-slime filler and sell it at an appropriate price for those consumers who are willing to buy it. I suspect that what most of us are upset about is that we have been buying ground beef for years that isn't really what we thought it was. I'm thankful that Costco ground beef doesn't contain pink-slime, since that what's we've been buying - I don't want my family eating stuff that has been treated with ammonia! However, if there are people that are willing to buy it for cost-savings, then let them do it. But the key is that full disclosure is a necessity.
Kaja Milutinovic March 27, 2012 at 12:57 pm
I agree!! Choices should be left to the consumer. I am however very discouraged with the lack of creditablity of the entire system from the USDA all the way to the actual manufacturers to the grocery stores that sell this stuff. It makes me wonder if all the organic items I buy daily are really organic.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Vienna Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something