.

Speak Out: Senators Criticize Treatment Of Protesters

Tell us: Were riot police, SWAT teams necessary for safety around Richmond or was it an overreaction?

At Monday's Virginia Senate session, Sens. Janet Howell (D-32nd) and Chap Petersen (D-34th) denounced the use of riot police, SWAT teams carrying automatic weapons, police dogs and helicopters in response to what they called peaceful protests in Capitol Square.

Protest groups have gathered several times at the square this session in the wake of legislation aimed at limiting abortion rights.

On Saturday, 31 protesters were arrested — mostly for trespassing or unlawful assembly — on the state capitol steps following a women's rights rally. Prior to some of the arrests, protesters were monitored by a fully armored police SWAT team carrying automatic weapons, riot police, and police dogs, the senators said.

"They were chanting, 'Tell me what democracy looks like! This is what democracy looks like!' And it was! Peaceful demonstrators going to the seat of government to express their views. In this case, they were marching and chanting for women’s rights," Howell said. " And what did they force? SWAT teams, state police in full riot gear, police armed with semi-automatic guns, and dogs, dogs! Not since the massive resistance days in the '60s have I seen such a disgraceful display of excessive police presence in my state."

And it wasn't the first time, Howell and Petersen said from the floor Monday: On Feb. 20, protesters gathered on the capitol grounds for a silent protest and rally to defend women's rights.  They were monitored by riot police, a police helicopter, and "countless uniformed and plainclothes officers." No incidents were reported.

On Feb. 27, protesters holding a candlelit vigil to 'Take Back the Night' on public property outside of the Governor's Mansion were responded to by a fully armed SWAT team carrying automatic weapons as well as an armored police vehicle.

"Since the very first day of this session, things have been going seriously awry.
On Jan. 10, Virginia had a well-deserved reputation as a moderate, pro-business, civil, and peaceful state. But now ... our state capitol is becoming an armed garrison. Peaceful demonstrators are being intimidated and arrested," Howell said on Monday.

The senators put responsibility for the response on Gov. Bob McDonnell's office; the governor's office said it was not involved in making those decisions.

"The governor played no role in the security response and was not at home at the time of the protest," Press Secretary Jeff Caldwell said. "The governor does not play any role in directing security at the Capitol."

The office did not offer comment on whether they thought the response was appropriate.

Capitol Police led efforts Saturday, assisted by Virginia State Police.

Capitol Police could not be reached for comment.

VSP Spokeswoman Corinne Geller said the department "routinely supplements security at the State Capitol and surrounding state buildings any time there is a gathering of significant size and population. Our presence is simply to ensure the safety of all individuals on the State Capitol campus — event participants, state employees, public officials, tourists, etc."

Petersen said the right to protest was fundamental to Virginia's identity, regardless of whether the views expressed by protesters are shared by those on the Capitol.

"Would we permit our wives, our sisters, our mothers and daughters to be treated this way in our homes? In our communities? I speak not as a State Senator, but as a man who is the son of a Virginian, married to a Virginian and the father of Virginians. It’s not right to see our Virginia women treated this way. We are a free society. This is a public square. People have a right to protest, without harassment or intimidation," Petersen said.

Tell us: Were the riot police, SWAT teams put in place necessary for safety around Richmond, or, was it "an overreaction by the Governor's office?" Leave a comment below.

Mart DC March 05, 2012 at 09:27 PM
The protesters made there point. The cops did their job. No one got hurt.
Mart DC March 05, 2012 at 09:30 PM
The protesters made their point. The cops did their job. No one got hurt.
David David March 05, 2012 at 09:52 PM
Speak Out: Senators Monday morning quarterback instead of guiding the public in the first place.
Peter L. Spain March 06, 2012 at 12:25 AM
Absurd deployment way out of proportion.
Ellen22124 March 06, 2012 at 01:38 AM
There is no reason to have that level of police presence for peaceful assembly. Seems to me someone was trying to intimidate people into staying home.
Cyndi Simpson March 06, 2012 at 02:05 AM
This is all about intimidation. A completely unnecessary show of force. And....what a complete waste of money! Such personpower is not "free;" those folks were probably all making time and a half or double overtime. Wrong all the way around. A foolish misuse of taxpayer resources deployed for political ends.
Doug R March 06, 2012 at 02:56 AM
Of course it wasn't warranted!!
Ann March 06, 2012 at 03:48 AM
Absolutely intimidation!! No question. This is absurd. As for the Governor not directing security.... are they trying to say that the Governor is not the Chief Executive of this Commonwealth, that we are a Police State where the Police are the ultimate authority? I certainly hope not! Hold McDonnell responsible and accountable now.
Terry Lee March 06, 2012 at 12:13 PM
Exactly. Law enforcement was totally professional in the video. That 31 protesters were arrested for breaking the law indicates their presence was needed. Would expect the same response for an Occupy Richmond or Pro-Life demonstration of the same size in that location.
Paul Brown March 06, 2012 at 01:10 PM
Definitely intimidation. And, unfortunately (as the warrant-serving FCPD SWAT team has shown us), those weapons will eventually be used.
john runyon March 06, 2012 at 01:40 PM
va. is still a backward state living in it's reprehensible past nice to see things never change jrr
JCD March 06, 2012 at 05:27 PM
YES they were neccessary! The occupy movement is about intimidation. It's nothing more than a handful of paid instigators leading a mob of unemploy(ed)(able) sheep, into an anarchist's dream. Stop the Occupy Violence. Thank you VSP for keeping the peace and avoiding the violence perpetrated on Oakland, CA
MadMom3 March 07, 2012 at 02:42 AM
I attended the Women's Health rally with my 10-year-old daughter. Crowd was mostly women--grandmas, moms, and students. A number of children and babies. Mood was mellow. Police were in number but mellow. A handful of young protesters decided they wanted to be arrested, so they plunked themselves on the steps and would not move. Fine. The cops started carrying them off and the crowd stood and watched. No biggie. This was around 2:30, for a rally that was set to end at 3. But then a large batallion of storm troopers arrived along with a SWAT team with machine guns and tear gas and attack dogs. At that point, any respect or appreciation anyone had for law enforcement went completely out the window. What sort of sick mind sends machine guns in where there are children? And for Governor McDonnell to try to spin this as lack of support for police and blame this on the protesters is OUTRAGEOUS. Machine guns for people who are SITTING?! Attack dogs for grandmas and pregnant women?! This was my first protest ever, but because of those machine guns and the governor's reaction to the presence of those machine guns, I am going to clear my schedule and start becoming a regular. I will leave my kid at home. But lookout GOP thugs, because this mom is now super duper mad!!
Mike James March 08, 2012 at 03:08 PM
What country can preserve its liberties if its rulers are not warned from time to time that their people preserve the spirit of resistance? ~Thomas Jefferson

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »